The Pastor was really surprised when I told him about the forums I found for homeless people. He’s from another generation and couldn’t really understand how the homeless can maintain a blog or the purpose of creating or contributing to forums.
I explained that it’s really a no-brainer when you think about it: Almost every library in America has computers available with free internet access. Lots of chronically homeless people spend most of their days at the library, because it’s the one place where you can sit around all day inside with access to a toilet where you never have to buy anything and they can’t ask you to leave if you’re not bothering anyone. A homeless Mecca, if you will.
Overseas, where this may not be as common, there are loads of internet cafes that are cheap places to spend a lot of time out of the cold wind or away from the hot sun.
So it’s no far stretch at all for them to jump online and create a blog or go to one of the online begging sites or contribute to one forum or other.
When I lived in overseas, I met an American guy who had been homeless for a while and maintained a blog. It actually worked out very well for him, if you only look at externals. He found a patron who supported him for more than a year to the tune of $25- $30,000 USD: That took the form of more than $1,000 a month for the rent of a 2-bedroom apartment for a year and an equal amount in spending money. There were also extras: bonuses and trips, a computer, a safe and other perks. Eventually, he was deported for not maintaining a visa, but not before he found another naive patron who was willing to set him up in another country. He now operates several online porn sites, but to listen to him in person, or read his blog, he’s the soul of moral integrity.
Most of the rhetoric out there by and/or about homelessness is of the politically-correct or liberally-minded variety. In addition, it’s only natural for a person to put his or her own situation in the best possible light. Even people who pride themselves on being unbiased and brutally honest do this; some of the people who think they are the most brutal about themselves and their situations are the most prone to sugar coat the reasons for their continued homelessness.
Still, if you are truly familiar with homelessness and can read between the lines, there is a lot of information to be found in forums and blogs maintained by the homeless. Sometimes, you even find dirty little secrets that they usually don’t like to let out, like this quote from a homeless panhandler:
Ok, I know what you are thinking, there are the people that spend that money on drugs or alcohol. To be completely honest you are correct. Most of the panhandlers I have met have serious addictions and some of them are not even homeless to begin with. This is ironic but after what I’ve seen I will think twice before I give my money to someone holding a sign in the future. Let me just give you a quick snapshot of what I am talking about. Two guys I know hold signs even though they are not homeless. They stay in a hotel, do drugs, and collect SSI. The worst part is one guy puts a fake cast on his arm and the other guy stands on the freeway offramp with a cane yet he walks perfectly fine after he’s done and walks away. Another guy I know holds a sign saying he’s an Iraq Vetran which he is not, he’s never even been in the military. He spends his money on beer, weed, and gambling. I mean he blows it. Give if you want to but don’t be naive where your money is going. I’m just being blunt and telling it like it is. Panhandlers don’t want you to know the truth.
Most of the homeless who blog consider it their divinely-inspired duty to critique the efforts that others make on their behalf. I’d really be interested in any statistics available that track just how many people who become and then continue to actively help the homeless were formerly homeless. I’m not talking about people who volunteer at the shelter that they have to live at because they want a meal upgrade or not to be forced to leave every morning, but people who work their way off the streets and then go back to work full-time in a shelter or other organization that deals directly with and primarily for the homeless. I would think that the numbers of these individuals when compared to those who were never homeless would be low. I might be wrong, but I don’t think so.
I think that most of the chronically homeless continue as they are, not because they don’t have any options, but because they have a flaw in their character that allows them to accept a lower standard of living than the average person would. I have had a few bouts of homelessness in my lifetime and the reason that I always worked my way off the streets very quickly was because I couldn’t stand to live at such a low comfort level. Notice that I didn’t say that’s why they became homeless, but what makes them accept their condition for so long.
Once they’ve accepted their condition as normal, the ones who are activists usually follow a predictable pattern: They start out making appropriate observations and intelligent suggestions, but their dialogue invariably degenerates into a list of entitlement demands.
Take this list of “suggestions” made by a homeless blogger about a program where various churches in the Nashville area pick up the homeless from a central point and take them to their own facilities or individual homes for a meal and a night’s sleep:
- When the homeless arrive at your church, they are tired.
Here he starts out with an appropriate observation that many well-meaning workers might not have considered.
- Homeless people want to have as much space as you can afford to give them.
No doubt. Don’t we all? His sense of entitlement is starting to show through in this one. Naturally people want their own personal spaces not to be intruded upon, but we all, homeless or not, have to face situations where we have to put up with crowding. In the paragraphs just before and just after this bullet point, he complains that there’s not enough space between beds in some facilities and that they’re crowded into church vans. I find it just too hilarious that he feels it necessary to add ” …especially with other homeless people…”
When I lived overseas, I often stayed in hostels where the conditions were far worse than any of the shelters I’ve ever stayed at and on top of that, had to pay a pretty penny for the privilege. Some of them didn’t even offer linen for the beds. I’ve been crammed into airplanes for 18-hour flights in seats that were so narrow an Ethiopian would feel crowded, had the guy next to me snoring and leaning his drooling face on my shoulder and had to pay several hundred dollars for the experience. The homeless and all-too-often their advocates somehow have this idea that the free conditions offered them should be consistently superior to those that the working non-homeless pay for.
- Most homeless people would rather you not preach to them.
I suggest then that most homeless people go to the shelters operated by Atheists.
If they can find such an animal.
- Homeless people have standards.
This one is so telling. On one level it’s a serious “duh” moment. Who doesn’t have any standards? On most levels though, it’s just his sense of entitlement complaining that the free accommodations that he’s being provided are not up to snuff.
Tuff.
- Engage homeless people when appropriate.
This is another fairly reasonable observation, but smacks a bit to me of expecting the workers to be mind readers.
- What you have the homeless sleep on makes a difference.
Again, who doesn’t know that an army cot or a mat on the floor are not the most comfortable sleeping surfaces? The underlying premise is that: A) he assumes we’re not doing the best we can with what we have and B) we don’t care.
I’m not implying that all homeless people don’t have common sense or have no real concept of what it takes to be a manager or organize successful products or services, but an unsurprisingly large percentage of them don’t. Hasn’t this writer considered that there was an ad-hoc or steering committee in charge of working out all of the details on how these churches would deal with the homeless people they serve?
There is an additional element that none of the homeless like to consider: the more comfortable you make it for the chronically homeless, the less likely they are to be motivated to change. Like it or not, every person in the world who works with the homeless does so with the intent of getting these people off the streets.
It never fails that well-intentioned people who want to help the homeless listen to these homeless individuals and give far more credence to their opinions than they deserve. Working with the homeless requires a particular mindset that seems very counter-intuitive. I had to undergo a radical paradigm shift when I went from thoughtful about the homeless situation to actively working with the homeless. I think that the best rule of thumb for those who are concerned, but not actively involved, would be to trust those who are active in the field and not the homeless themselves, whose judgment and choices have (after all) already proven to be less-than-sufficient to meet their own needs.